Homepage

Andrew Dixon
Who am I
My CV
My on-line shop
Contact me
Mailing List

My Bands
The Nairobi Trio
Blues Brothers
Solo Act

Recordings
The Art of Sax Vol.1
The Art of Sax, Vol.2
Sax in Your Stocking
My on-line shop

Books
Quick & Easy PC1
Quick & Easy PC2
MS Office Made Easy

Sax Pages
Brand Vs Price
Tips when buying
Which sax is best
Types of Saxes
Brands of Saxes
Mouthpiece guide
Mouthpiece facings
Playing tips
Reed tips
Sax first aid
Maintenance tips
Fingering chart
Sax History
Sax Players

Sax Resources

For Soprano sax
For Alto sax
For Tenor sax
For Baritone sax

Clarinet Pages
What Clarinet to buy
Clarinet Reeds
Clarinet Fingering Chart

Photography
View Gallery

Links
Handy Links

 

 

Which is the best Saxophone?
By Paul R. Coats Source:Sax On The Web
SELMER | YAMAHA | YANIGASAWA | KEILWERTH | LA SAX | LEGACY | CECILIO | JUPITER

There is no definitive answer. All of the major manufacturers, and even the< smaller manufacturers, know how to shape the bore, where to place the tone holes, and other factors in making a Saxophone play well. Just as in choosing an automobile, choosing a Saxophone depends on looking at the various features, and finding those that are meaningful to you.

This article is not going to tell you which is the "best Saxophone", as that is not possible. In the following paragraphs, I will go over the features that make each of the major brands stand apart from its rivals.

SELMER
 

Selmer is, by far, the Saxophone to which all others are compared. Years ago, Selmer set a very high standard with their famous Mk. VI--a quantum leap ahead of all the other manufacturers.

The current lineup from Selmer is comprised of the Super Action 80 Series II and Series III instruments. Both series are being marketed simultaneously. The Series III alto has an additional tone hole that opens for middle C#, bringing this usually flat note up to pitch. This feature is not included in the tenor or soprano, though the Selmer sopranos, and most other brands, already have a double pad assembly that accomplishes the same purpose.
Several new models have been announced.

The Series II soprano has a range to high F#, and a straight, one-piece body. The Series III soprano has a range to high G, and two removable necks, one straight, one curved.

Selmer USA has two professional models, the AS-110 alto, and TS-100 tenor. These have many of the same features as the Series II Paris models, but at a lower price. The key hinges are of conventional design.

Selmer continues to manufacture their Eb Sopranino and Bb Bass Saxophones.

Selmer Sopranos >>
Selmer Altos >>
Selmer Tenors >>

Selmer Baritones >>



YAMAHA
 

Yamaha is Selmer's biggest rival in the Saxophone market. There are two professional models in the Yamaha lineup, the 62 series, and the Custom series. There are adjustments for each key in the upper and lower stack in the 62 series instruments. This makes setup of the instrument, and fine tuning by the repairman much easier. I am very surprised other Saxophone manufacturers have not copied this feature. The Custom models strangely lack this feature. The Custom also has Selmer Mk VI style ball joints on the side C and side Bb keys. Experience with the Mk. VI has shown that with years of wear, the ball joints get rather noisy. Fortunately, the Oleg side key silencers can correct this poor feature. Otherwise, the Custom is a very fine saxophone.

Though the 62 series is nice, the Custom series keywork really feels good to me. While nearly all manufacturers have gone from the round pearl front F to a spatula design, the shape and placement of the Custom's front F spatula is the best I have seen. There is a subtle tone difference between the 62 and Custom, the Custom being slightly brighter to some listeners.

Yamaha Sopranos >>
Yamaha Altos >>Yamaha Tenors >>
Yamaha Baritones >>

YANAGISAWA
   

Yanagisawa, from G. Leblanc Corp. in the U. S., has some outstanding mechanical features. With the 990 and 991 series, Yanagisawa has incorporated many of the custom modifications offered by the top Saxophone repairmen. These include double arms on low C and B natural pad cups, and F# helper linkage to insure proper closing of this pad. The Yanagisawa Saxes have an excellent, tight "core" to the tone. This is subjective, but is my observation. This company is now offering solid silver body parts in its lineup.

Yanagisawa was the first major manufacturer in recent years to bring back the curved soprano. They have continued to refine this instrument by adding a front F spatula and improved, independent, palm keys.

Yanagisawa offers straight and curved sopranos, and a sopranino. The S991 soprano offers a high G key, and two necks.

Yanagisawa Sopranos >>
Yanagisawa Altos >>
Yanagisawa Tenors >>Yanagisawa Baritones >>



KEILWERTH
   

Keilwerth saxophones are designed by Mr. Herb Couf. In designing these saxophones, Mr. Couf appears to have started with a clean drawing board, and not copied or modified Selmer's Saxophones. They incorporate some features not found in the other top brands. One feature immediately noticeable is the larger radius of the bow, and bigger flare of the bell. This is Mr. Couf's solution to the difficult low end. One drawback, these Saxes do not fit into just any case, but Keilwerth offers excellent, roadworthy cases as standard equipment. Rolled tone holes on their top models give increased pad life and better sealing. The palm keys are adjustable for height and angle. There is also an F# helper mechanism, bridging from the F pad, to positively close the F# pad. The most outstanding feature is their positive opening mechanism for the G# pad. No more wrong notes from a stuck G# on these Saxes!

Keilwerth has an excellent straight alto. The neck is of conventional design, but the main body tube is straight all the way to the end of the bell, which tips forward, Saxello style. The tone bounces off the floor, and has a milder, warm tone. This alto may appeal to classical players, for solo or quartet work. I would think it could be used to good effect in a pit orchestra.

Keilwerth also manufactures a bass Saxophone.

Keilwerth Sopranos >>
Keilwerth Altos >>
Keilwerth Tenors >>
Keilwerth Baritones >>

Other Brands to Check out

LA Sax
Makers of pretty groovy saxes. Check out the range and you will see why. I play an LA Sax Tenor and love it.
LA SAX Sopranos >>LA SAX Altos >> LA SAX Tenors >>
LEGACY
Very affordable with meny options and add-ons for the beginner and pro.
Legacy Sopranos >>
Legacy Altos >>
Legacy Tenors >>
Legacy Baritones >>

Cecilio
Another very affordable brand with meny model options and price ranges.
Cecilio Sopranos >>
Cecilio Altos >>
Cecilio Tenors >>
Cecilio Baritones >>

Jupiter
Jupiter have been manufacturing saxophones for some time now and constantly improove their instruments. A good mid-priced sax.
Jupiter Sopranos >>
Jupiter Altos >>
Jupiter Tenors >>
Jupiter Baritones >>

For a comprehensive list of the many other brands available and to view each of their saxes, Click here >>

;